ourschoolboard.org

District news

Brayton Elementary School gets a new principal mid-year

Admin hiring
Third grade students at Brayton Elementary School planted flowers and vegetables in this planter box outside their school in Summit, New Jersey. The plants growing in July over the summer.
Tomwsulcer · cc0

What happened

Brayton Elementary School changed principals in the middle of the 2025-2026 school year. The board accepted the resignation of principal Shane Zeigler effective December 19, 2025, and at its December 18, 2025 meeting appointed Mary Jane Custy as principal at a prorated salary of $134,300, effective February 9, 2026 or sooner. The superintendent told the board in January that she would begin on February 2, 2026. A principal search had been running: the communications committee reported an update on the Brayton principal search in November 2025. Brayton had also been the subject of repeated parent concern about class size during the same period, with residents raising the size of a second-grade class at the October 2025 meeting and class size appearing in education committee reports in November.

Why it matters to families

The principal is the person a Brayton family deals with day to day, and a mid-year change means a new leader arriving in February with a school already in motion. The timing matters for the parents who had been pressing the previous administration on class size: those conversations restart with someone new. There was a roughly six-week gap between the outgoing principal's last day in December and the new principal's start in February.

The evidence

The December 18, 2025 agenda and minutes record the appointment of Mary Jane Custy as principal of Brayton Elementary School at $134,300 prorated, effective February 9, 2026 or sooner for the 2025-2026 school year, replacing Shane Zeigler. The November 13, 2025 agenda and minutes record the acceptance of Shane Zeigler's resignation as principal of Brayton Elementary School effective December 19, 2025 and the communications committee's report on the Brayton principal search. The January 15, 2026 minutes record the superintendent reporting that the new Brayton principal, Mary Jane Custy, would begin on February 2. The October 9, 2025 minutes record a resident raising the size of a second-grade class at Brayton School and asking that it be addressed.

The source

Minutes, December 18, 2025 regular board meeting

Share this story

Help your community stay informed about the decisions that affect your schools.

Get alerts like this for Summit Public School District

We read every agenda, packet, and set of minutes, and write up the decisions that affect families — each one linked to the document it came from, the moment it's public.

Get personalized alerts